Jump to content

Photo

Stormcloak or Imperial?

- - - - -

  • Please log in to reply
77 replies to this topic

Poll: A curious poll on the Civil war (64 member(s) have cast votes)

Which side, if any, did you choose in the Civil war?

  1. Voted Stormcloak rebels (24 votes [34.29%])

    Percentage of vote: 34.29%

  2. Imperials (24 votes [34.29%])

    Percentage of vote: 34.29%

  3. Neither (16 votes [22.86%])

    Percentage of vote: 22.86%

  4. Both (6 votes [8.57%])

    Percentage of vote: 8.57%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1
Hanaisse

Hanaisse

    Moderator

  • Investors
  • 1,998 posts


Users Awards
Just out of curiosity, which side did you choose in the Civil war?

Are you a rebellious Stormcloak at heart or a staunch Imperial? Did you decide to not choose sides? Have you played multiple characters just to play both sides?
Please feel free to explain your decision.


Myself, I've played two characters so far and both are strong Stormcloak supporters. I truly believe the Nords should run their own country. And I won't support anyone who almost had me executed for no good reason. :) Oh, and because I'm in love with Ulfric too.


(You can choose more than one option)
(Please be respectful of other people's opinions)
  • 0

#2
Tamira

Tamira

    Senior Member

  • Senior Allies
  • 742 posts


Users Awards
Level 43 now and I still let them fight their fights :rofl:
No, I never chose any side :)
  • 0

#3
WillieSea

WillieSea

    Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 5,214 posts


Users Awards
If we are going to say 'Stormcloak Rebel', then the others should be called 'Imperial Dogs'. :lol: Lackys to the Thalmore (said with disgust). I believe that is how the stormcloaks portray them.

When the Imperials walked me to the chopping block, when my name was not on the list, it was instant hate. If they could kill anyone who just happened to be walking through that pass at that time, then I was not going to accept their rule. I admit, the Nords are not much better against the forsworn, but it just galled me that they tried to kill 'ME'!
  • 1

#4
lilith

lilith

    Captain

  • TESA Team II
  • 1,197 posts


Users Awards
I voted "neither," and although I've played the main quest through to completion I've found little interest in the civil war. In saying that though, I do expect at some point to give in to curiosity and play both sides. I'd have to see what the "other side" is like... LOL Stormcloaks first though, because like WillieSea said, my name wasn't on the list and it didn't make any difference to the Imperial Dogs.

Edit: I forgot the reference to who was doing the killing XD
  • 0

#5
Arthmoor

Arthmoor

    Ambassador

  • Ambassadors
  • 914 posts


Users Awards
Though I've played one character on each side, I'll go with my first run. Stormcloak all the way. Legate Rikke deserved the knife she got in her gullet later for so casually condemning me to the block. The Empire is weak and must be purged and even though Ulfric is a racist pig, he still allowed a lizard to fight for the cause.
  • 1

#6
Arion

Arion

    Senior Member

  • Senior Allies
  • 1,624 posts


Users Awards
Guess I'm the lone guy out here.... I've played it out on the Imperial side because in the process of running after the dragon attacked the Imperial guy with the list is the first person I saw and he had an arrow over his head.. so I followed him..... turns out he was a pretty decent guy, thanked me for helping him escape the carnage, said I was forgiven in his eyes and that I ought to go to Solitude and join the imperials. I waited a long time before choosing what side and it was basically the only thing left to do in quests. It sealed the deal whenever I got near stormcloaks I was attacked on sight, which wasn't much different than being attacked by Thalmor, but at least I was never attacked in any of the imperial camps.

My last 3 play throughs I've refused to choose a side because the whole civil war thing is bogus anyway. Ulfric is an idiot whose fanning the flames for his own personal glory and the imperials arent' any better.

Edited by Arion, 03 April 2012 - 04:04 AM.

  • 0

#7
donnato

donnato

    Senior Member

  • Senior Allies
  • 3,843 posts


Users Awards
Ok well after hearing these explainations I`m leaning toward the stormcloaks...but where do the "Blades" figure in...?

Edited by donnato, 03 April 2012 - 04:14 AM.

  • 0

#8
Hanaisse

Hanaisse

    Moderator

  • Investors
  • 1,998 posts


Users Awards

Ok well after hearing these explainations I`m leaning toward the stormcloaks...but where do the "Blades" figure in...?

There are no more Blades.
Well, there is, two of them, but they only care about the dragons, not interested in Skyrim politics. :)
  • 0

#9
ResolveThatChord

ResolveThatChord

    Disciple

  • Allies
  • 377 posts


Users Awards
Morrowind and Oblivion biased me heavily against the empire, but as Dragonborn I have the most legitimate claim to the Imperial throne. Skyrim belongs to the Nords? Maybe now. But soon all of Tamriel will belong to me. :noway:
  • 0

#10
Windmill Tilter

Windmill Tilter

    Lt. Commander

  • TESA Team
  • 824 posts


Users Awards
I went Stormcloak. Bugged me a little at first, as I saw myself as an Imperial patriot in Oblivion. I happily joined the Blades and had Martin's back. However it became obvious right off that things had changed, and I've always been a fan of the underdog. It's hard not to want to side with rebels against any power that rules with such a heavy hand, and when they decided to execute me for no reason at all the choice was made. Down with the Empire! :starwars:

That said I'll certainly play a character through as an Imperial at some point, just to see how it plays out.

WT
  • 1

#11
charlescrowe

charlescrowe

    Scout

  • Allies
  • 709 posts


Users Awards
eh, i play a character that's been around since the oblivion invasion... personally, i feel the "empire" died with martin. my first play through , i didn't do the civil war until about level 25, in which i joined the stormcloaks... it left a bad taste in my mouth after certain documents and paradigms rose to the surface. since then, i've been akin to legate rikke...
  • 0

#12
bradleyh

bradleyh

    Layman

  • Allies
  • 5 posts
I dislike Ulfric, but the Stormcloaks are the faction most of my characters play. I can not support the Empire as it is in Skyrim.
I hope that Legate Rikke will survive the Official history, She does not deserve the end She recieves in the end of the Stormcloak questline. I would like to have an option to let her live out her life in Skyrim.
  • 0

#13
charlescrowe

charlescrowe

    Scout

  • Allies
  • 709 posts


Users Awards

I dislike Ulfric, but the Stormcloaks are the faction most of my characters play. I can not support the Empire as it is in Skyrim.
I hope that Legate Rikke will survive the Official history, She does not deserve the end She recieves in the end of the Stormcloak questline. I would like to have an option to let her live out her life in Skyrim.

eh, when you think about it... Rikke dies a good death. fighting for what she believes. sure, she may not agree with the W/G concordon't, but she swore an oath of loyalty in her beliefs, and her empire. the same can be said of Galmar Stonefist. (who's voice actor i really like. Grandpa Max Tennyson ftw!)
  • 0

#14
the-manta

the-manta

    Blade

  • Allies
  • 1,279 posts


Users Awards

Legate Rikke deserved the knife she got in her gullet later for so casually condemning me to the block.


That wasn't Rikke, she wasn't at Helgen, that was some nameless "Imperial Captain" (whom you kill if you follow Ralof).

I went Imperial because while there's some real issues there (yeah that execution was not on...) I find the Stormcloaks shortsighted and unpleasant. Ulfric is essentially a Hitler figure- a charismatic ruler with a military background riding a wave of nationalism for his own personal power. The Stormcloak rebellion helps no one but the Thalmor.

Contrary to popular Stormcloak belief, the Empire is not under the control, or even allied to the Aldmeri Dominion, it represents mankinds only chance of being strong enough to defeat the elves. If The entire Empire could only just survive the Great War (and while the concordat is unpalatable for all, it did allow them to fight another day). The Empire needs to build its strength before the Dominion can (biology is on their side since elves reproduce slower), and the Civil War drains time, resources and blood.

If you follow Hadvar and listen to Alvor the blacksmith he will point out that before the Markarth Incident, which effectively started the rebellion (the Jarl of Markarth is, frankly, a moron...) the ban on Talos worship was barely enforced- everyone still worshipped Talos, they just did so quietly in their homes to avoid problems.

The White Gold Concordat is unpleasant for everyone in the Empire (Talos is an Imperial hero as much as a Nordic one, he founded the Empire after all), but it was necessary to give mankind a fighting chance.

Overall, I believe:
- Ulfric is false, and the rebellion is all for him
- The Empire is humanity's last, best hope
- The Stormcloaks are shortsighted and don't appreciate the threat posed by the real enemy, the Aldmeri Dominion.
  • 1

#15
MalachiDelacot

MalachiDelacot

    Senior Member

  • Senior Allies
  • 20 posts


Users Awards
I haven't chosen a side yet because I haven't talked to the Yarl in Windhelm yet. For that matter, I still have the Dragon Stone. Decided to do the guild quests first before the civil war and the main quest. Right now, chances are going with the Stormcloaks because I see the Imperials as invaders. Ulfric just better be polite to my character because she hates rudeness. In Oblivion, Gersilla let the Gray Fox sit in that house in Bruma for two weeks game time because he pist her off.

Edited by malachidelacot, 28 April 2012 - 11:17 PM.

  • 0

#16
Carah

Carah

    Senior Member

  • Senior Allies
  • 105 posts


Users Awards
I believe Nords should govern their own country, but I'd like to give Ulfrich a good swift kick in the arse. My character, being Breton with some Nord ancestry was torn after reading the book "The Bear of Markarth"

Edited by Carah, 30 April 2012 - 04:38 PM.

  • 1

#17
WillieSea

WillieSea

    Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 5,214 posts


Users Awards
I like to think the Dovakiin can and WILL stomp Ulfrich in the end after tossing the imperials out of Skyrim. And rule the land! Why else would you have all that power, make an empire like the 'dragon bloods' did in Oblivion.
  • 0

#18
vometia

vometia

    Ambassador

  • Ambassadors
  • 962 posts


Users Awards
I chose the Imperial side but without a great deal of enthusiasm or conviction: we didn't exactly get off to a good start what with them hassling me with their executioner and the Empire seems to have gone the usual way of empires, becoming somewhat corrupt, bureaucratic and impotent; but then you have the Stormcloaks, which seem to be the ugly face of nationalism, so I'm not desperately keen on them either. But where you have "not desperately keen" on either of the above, the Thalmor are a hateful threat and the Imperials represent the best chance of dealing with the menace they pose, and may even return to some of their former glory in the process, so I sided with them.

The representation of the men on the ground seemed realistic enough in that they generally seemed an okay bunch for the most part so in both cases, whatever disagreements I had was with their leadership: and I found Ulfric Stormcloak to be most disagreeable.
  • 0

#19
Dhoone

Dhoone

    Initiate

  • Allies
  • 21 posts
I've been playing as Nords on all of my characters and in all my games I've sided with the Stormcloaks. Not only was it the fact that they tried to execute me that lead me too choose the Stormcloaks and the fact that they signed away the worship of a GOD in the w/g but the fact that the first person I see in Whiterun was a imperial supporter and ****** bag, then later on I saw his family bullying an old lady about the war. I agree that the Stormcloaks are narrowminded but I believe that Skyrim should be run by Nords and that they need someone with greater morals (me of course) around when all is said and done to lead them in the righteous direction. Also the fact that the Empire was willing to execute everyone they found made them seem too desperate, as if they are already too weak to fight. I believe that if the empire with all its legions is not strong enough to defeat a rebel faction that is only supported less than half of its nation that the Empire is supposed to protect that they should forfeit Skyrim to the "True Nords" and sign a treaty of their own to allow each power to become stronger in their own rights.
  • 0

#20
Tigersong

Tigersong

    Scout

  • Allies Ad-Free
  • 582 posts
I might have to say neither. Honestly, I want the option to run with the dragons! But in any case I can't forget Hadvar- after all, he's an Imperial, yet is willing to help me out.
  • 0




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users